נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

אחראי: יאנאש

Porfavor
שר חמישים ומאתים
תגובות: 350
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: מאנטאג יולי 17, 2017 8:07 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך Porfavor »

רעגנדיג האט געשריבן: דינסטאג אפריל 18, 2023 8:21 am
image (2).png
איר קענט קאפי פעיסטן דעם ארטיקל?
מען קען עס נאר ליינען מיט א סובסקריפשן.
אוועטאר
רעגנדיג
שר שבעת אלפים
תגובות: 7203
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: זונטאג יאנואר 30, 2022 9:15 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך רעגנדיג »

Porfavor האט געשריבן: דינסטאג אפריל 18, 2023 10:05 am
רעגנדיג האט געשריבן: דינסטאג אפריל 18, 2023 8:21 am
image (2).png
איר קענט קאפי פעיסטן דעם ארטיקל?
מען קען עס נאר ליינען מיט א סובסקריפשן.
וואס מאכט דיך טראכטן אז איך בין סובסקרייבד?...
באשיינפערליך האט געשריבן: מאנטאג פעברואר 05, 2024 1:48 am
איין זאך ווייסעך יא, איך זעה ווער ס׳שטייט אויף וועמענס צד… דאס זאגט מיר פונקטליך וואו איך זאל שטיין…
ערמון
שר חמישים ומאתים
תגובות: 386
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: דינסטאג יאנואר 07, 2014 11:19 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך ערמון »

Porfavor האט געשריבן: דינסטאג אפריל 18, 2023 10:05 am
רעגנדיג האט געשריבן: דינסטאג אפריל 18, 2023 8:21 am
image (2).png
איר קענט קאפי פעיסטן דעם ארטיקל?
מען קען עס נאר ליינען מיט א סובסקריפשן.
Are Jewish moms and dads who send their children to religious schools lawbreakers? Or are they exercising their right to live by their beliefs—even if those beliefs are out of fashion with modern American sensibilities?

The New York State Education Department is targeting Hasidic Jews for running yeshivas it says do not equip students with the skills necessary for 21st-century life. An 1895 New York law requires that children in nonpublic schools receive an education “substantially equivalent” to that of a public school. But a few weeks ago a court in Albany ruled that yeshivas themselves can’t be held to this law, so the government now has to decide whether to escalate by going after the parents.

Certainly the demand for such schools is there. New York’s 450 Orthodox yeshivas have about 160,000 students. That puts them on par with the 163,000 in the state’s Catholic schools. But they are diverse, and the main issue appears to be 50,000 boys in the Hasidic yeshivas—which raises unique religious-liberty questions.

Catholic schools generally advertise themselves as providing a better secular education than public schools. But proficiency rates on subjects like math and English among the Hasidic boys who take standardized tests can be as low as in some of New York’s worst public schools. The difference is that the public schools are failing to teach these subjects, while yeshivas are succeeding at something else: providing an advanced education in Jewish texts and law in ancient Hebrew and Aramaic.

It’s just not the education the state wants, because yeshivas aim for something different: a Jewish life in service of God and the community.

America has all manner of religious communities living out beliefs the majority regard as eccentric. Is dissent from modern secular pieties now a crime? The concern isn’t rhetorical in a day when the Federal Bureau of Investigation deems Catholics who prefer the Latin Mass a potential domestic terror threat.

A New York Times investigative series into yeshivas upholds the dominant secular orthodoxy. The basic idea is that religious fanatics are condemning their children to lives of “joblessness and dependency.” The implication is that they are doing so with public money, too.

In response, Agudath Israel, an Orthodox Jewish umbrella group, sent a letter to the board of the Pulitzer Prize committee. It argues that the Times series draws almost exclusively from activist ex-Hasidic Jews and not the vast majority who are content with their schools, and that yeshiva grads earn above-average incomes. Others dispute the Times’s suggestion that the yeshivas disproportionately receive public benefits. The letter urges the board not to award the Times a Pulitzer.

But a Pulitzer is a side issue. The yeshivas’ real offense is to have different values from the state of New York.

The practical dilemma this raises involves New York’s compulsory-education law, the basis for the state’s authority. In “Free to Choose,” Milton Friedman made the case that even when these laws were passed more than a century ago, they were responding to a need that didn’t exist. Most kids were already attending schools.

The New York Sun agrees, and rightly says that getting rid of compulsory education would be a good solution. And if some public funds for child care or other services are being misused, the answer is to stop it—not upend a whole school system.

While a yeshiva education is not the best route to Harvard or a career at Google, parents might rate more highly having their kids in schools where they are safe from violence and drug use and learn how to live a faithful Jewish life. Especially if they believe this is how God wants them to live.

And if the state is going to hold parents to standards, why should the traditional public schools be the model? Why not one of Eva Moskowitz’s Success Academy charter schools? Or the Partnership Schools, a group of Catholic schools that, like Ms. Moskowitz’s charters, are giving black and Latino kids the education they aren’t getting at public schools?

Given tests suggesting that not even half the 1.1 million New York public-school kids in grades three through eight are proficient in math or English, does New York even have the credibility to impose standards on Hasidic parents? There’s another wrinkle. Even as performance declines, a new set of standards, from gender affirmation to critical race theory, is roiling public education. How long until these, too, are deemed essential for religious schools?

the end, it comes down to a philosophical question about who gets to decide: the government or parents. Certainly some yeshiva grads end up resenting the opportunities they may not have because of their education. But lots of kids resent the consequences of their parents’ choices.

The only real path left for New York to gets its way is to go to war with these yeshiva parents. Victory wouldn’t be worth the price.

Write to [email protected].
אוועטאר
אביש
שר חמישים ומאתים
תגובות: 369
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: פרייטאג פעברואר 02, 2018 12:26 am

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך אביש »

www-foxnews-com .pdf
אטעטשמענטס
www-foxnews-com.pdf
(229.46 KiB) געווארן דאונלאודעד 351 מאל
Without a name
שר חמש מאות
תגובות: 650
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: דאנערשטאג יאנואר 26, 2023 2:30 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך Without a name »

Screenshot_20230418_193905_WhatsApp.jpg
Screenshot_20230418_193905_WhatsApp.jpg (195.7 KiB) געזען 4408 מאל
קשורה בנפשו
שר חמש מאות
תגובות: 942
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: דאנערשטאג נאוועמבער 24, 2022 11:45 am

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך קשורה בנפשו »

דער שרייבט גאר גוט מ'האמיר דורכגעליינט דעם ארטיקל בנשימה אחת.

איין זאך לאזט ער אבער אויס, דעם פאקט אז מיר ישיבה גראדואירטע מאכן גאר שיין און יעדער אינגערמאן וואס וויל ארבעטן קען טרעפן א גוט באצאלטע פאזיציע.
אוועטאר
Jhon
שר שלשת אלפים
תגובות: 3503
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: מאנטאג אקטאבער 19, 2009 7:57 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך Jhon »

וואס איז דאס WSJ? זייער א גוטע ארטיקל, גוט געשריבן לויט זייער בליק
zugurnish
שר שלשת אלפים
תגובות: 3366
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: דינסטאג מאי 17, 2011 8:31 am

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך zugurnish »

פרעגסט ערענסט?
שטייט אפען
Wall Street journal
אוועטאר
Jhon
שר שלשת אלפים
תגובות: 3503
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: מאנטאג אקטאבער 19, 2009 7:57 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך Jhon »

Jhon האט געשריבן: דינסטאג אפריל 18, 2023 10:36 pm
וואס איז דאס WSJ? זייער א גוטע ארטיקל, גוט געשריבן לויט זייער בליק
@דער איד דעילי
"וואל סטריט זשורנאל"
אפּ-עד לטובת ניו יארק מוסדות


ניו יארק – די פּרעסטיזשפולע "וואל סטריט זשורנאל" האט פּובליצירט נעכטן אינדערפרי אן אפּ-עד ארטיקל אין וועלכע עס ווערן פארטיידיגט די מוסדות התורה והחינוך וועלכע קעמפן קעגן די ניו יארק סטעיט'ס פּרואוון ארויפצוצווינגען גזירות און צוימונגען אויפן ערליכן חינוך. דער עדיטאריעל איז געשריבן געווארן דורך וויליאם מעקגורן, א געוועזענער רעדע שרייבער פאר פּרעזידענט בוש און באקאנטער שרייבער אין אלגעמיין, און ער שרייבט אונטער'ן קעפּל "לאז ניו יארקער ישיבות אליינס". ער ערווענט אז די סטעיט זאל זיך אפּלאזן פון די שאנדפולע און לעכערליכע גזירות.
שמחהלע
שר האלף
תגובות: 1526
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: מיטוואך יאנואר 10, 2018 12:50 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך שמחהלע »

New York Times failed to get the Pulitzer prize for the 14 part series on the orthodox school system.
פלייוואד
שר חמישים ומאתים
תגובות: 422
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: מאנטאג מאי 18, 2009 3:46 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך פלייוואד »

פרישער פאזיטייוער ארטיקל אין וואשינגטאן עקזעמינאר אטאקירט די טיימס ארטיקלען

https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news ... ks-yeshiva
אוועטאר
דזשי רי בי
שר חמש מאות
תגובות: 700
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: מיטוואך אפריל 19, 2023 11:21 am
לאקאציע: גרינד

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך דזשי רי בי »

wex-logo-new-450.png
wex-logo-new-450.png (11.62 KiB) געזען 3153 מאל
https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news ... ks-yeshiva
The real story of New York's Yeshivas
A.G. Sulzberger, publisher of the New York Times, recently acknowledged the controversy surrounding his paper’s coverage of New York’s Hasidic yeshivas. Writing in the Columbia Journalism Review, Sulzberger declared, “The central criticism is not so much about the accuracy of the coverage itself, but whether it could be misused.”

In fact, from the beginning, experts have pointed out that the articles were filled with inaccuracies. One representative article was “rife with half-truths and distortions,” wrote Jason Bedrick and Jay P. Greene in this magazine in September.

Yet beyond the misrepresentations, another question has hung in the air: What did the New York Times leave out? Interviews with 34 people, including yeshiva graduates, parents, and teachers, along with education scholars and elected officials, 16 of whom contacted the New York Times or were interviewed by it, have now helped answer that.

The New York Times relied heavily on critics of the community and those who have left it. Giving the Hasidic community itself a voice in its own story, it turns out, upends the carefully crafted and selective narrative.

In its initial article, the New York Times asserted Hasidic parents “feel they have little choice but to send their children to the[se] schools.” But what the New York Times paints as peer pressure, said Rabbi Yaakov Menken, managing director of the Coalition for Jewish Values, is actually a genuine commitment to religious education and a religious life.

excuse to flee the yeshiva system, meet Moyshe Silk. He was assistant secretary for international markets at the Treasury Department after having already been a “senior partner at a global, elite law firm.” Silk, the first Hasid to serve as a senior presidential appointee, commuted to Washington during his three years in government “so my kids wouldn’t be uprooted from their school.” The Silks prioritized schooling because “educationally, we don’t think there’s better training for critical thinking and textual analysis. ... Our kids grow up well rounded, highly productive, with good communal and family values, and filled with optimism.” Yeshivas are “the crown jewel of the community.”

A central claim of the New York Times’s attack on religious education is that these yeshiva graduates are left unprepared for life after high school. But the yeshivas’ moral education translates nicely into practical use. Penina G., a registered nurse, credits her yeshiva education for making college feel easy “because I was taught how to study properly.” Beyond the life lessons, “curiosity and creativity were encouraged in school.”

Malka, a graduate of a Bobov Hasidic yeshiva, described the experience of her husband, now a doctoral candidate in molecular biology, in similar terms. It turns out that imparting analytical habits of mind is no mere abstraction. “He found that he was always at the top of his class [post-yeshiva] because of the way he had been trained to think,” Malka said. “The advanced analytical skills, logic development, and the rigorous questioning all stood him in good stead.”

In other words, a yeshiva education teaches skills that are applicable for students who go outside the community for further education and the workforce.

Just ask Assemblyman Simcha Eichenstein, the first Hasid elected to New York’s state legislature. “The yeshiva system produces outstanding young adults who have highly developed educational and critical thinking skills, are compassionate, generous, bright, and inquisitive,” Eichenstein said. That’s why their parents “are happy to pay considerably high tuition rates.” In general, the community’s parents see it as a good investment in their children’s futures.

But don’t the standardized test score data printed by the New York Times contradict that? Actually, no.

The New York Times's initial article cited “dismal outcomes” at the Central United Talmudical Academy and “nearly a dozen other schools.” Those unnamed schools were effectively precluded from refuting the charge that their students were “failing by design.”

Dr. Moshe Krakowski, professor and director of doctoral studies at Yeshiva University’s Azrieli Graduate School of Jewish Education and Administration and “the only [American] academic who studies Hasidic schools,” observed, “When they’re talking about test scores, they’re talking about 10 or 12 schools at the bottom of the distribution [of approximately 200 Hasidic yeshivas]. But they are in fact providing students the basics, even if it’s not showing up on test scores.”

Standardized test scores at Hasidic boys’ yeshivas can underwhelm for several reasons. First, yeshivas are unlikely to teach to the test. Second, there are “Hasidic schools [that] start secular studies a year later [than public schools do],” so some Hasidic students “are not being tested on what they’ve learned that year.” Put differently, third graders in a Hasidic yeshiva could cover the secular studies content public schools covered in second grade, meaning their statewide test covers material they won’t recognize. Third, there are schools where students’ ages may not line up with standardized testing’s expected pool. Taken together, that helps explain why the New York Times found that “only nine schools in the state had less than 1% of students testing at grade level in 2019. ... All of them were Hasidic boys schools.”

Part of the frustration with the New York Times’s distortions of test scores is that they are meant to give the impression that not only are yeshiva students doing terribly but also that nonreligious schools in New York are thriving, or even up to par. But a more complete look at the state’s students shows that’s not remotely the case.

Albany’s Times Union reported that in 2022, only “46.6 percent of [third through eighth grade] students [across New York] scored at or above grade level” in English, while “38.6 percent of students” did so in math. And of the 60% of Schenectady eighth graders tested on math, none passed.

Krakowski concluded, “Look at what’s going on elsewhere to see how crazy it is to get fourth, fifth grade kids to translate Aramaic legal texts [as they do in yeshiva] and have sophisticated legal arguments about rights, responsibilities, damages, and contracts. ... They’re operating at a very high level, and that’s most of their day.”

To underscore the point, a recent Princeton University graduate whose yeshiva taught nothing secular at all told the Washington Examiner that even in his case, “it’s not like it’s overly difficult to catch up with the standards of the public school system.” That’s probably why the students who come from the vast majority of yeshivas, which do teach secular studies, find they have a head start on advanced education.

Jeff Ballabon, a Yale Law School graduate who attended both Haredi, though not Hasidic, and Modern Orthodox yeshivas, described encountering the chasm between early secular and religious schooling: “At Yale, they give you ethical dilemmas to discuss among yourselves. Other than a small minority of students who had attended private religious schools, I was struck how almost none of the students had the language to talk about ethical concepts I’d grown up with since preschool. ... My first observation of the outside world was that that which concerned us primarily, they never addressed at all.”

Ray Domanico, senior fellow and director of education policy at the Manhattan Institute, visited “three boys’ yeshivas in Brooklyn” and mostly observed Talmud classes. He recounted, “It is not rote memorization of Scripture or prayers. It’s what we call in public education ‘critical thinking.’” Domanico recalled seeing “boys as young as third and fourth grade having very advanced discussions about how to resolve various commentaries on the Scriptures.”

Yeshiva education is also rigorous from the outset. Domanico recalled being “kind of impressed” seeing “a young staff member” tracking second grade boys’ Hebrew reading comprehension. The school expected Hebrew literacy “by the end of first grade.” By contrast, “charter and public schools in New York State don’t test for English reading proficiency until third grade.”

“I’m not saying there are no problems,” Domanico clarified. “What I am saying is that I saw other things going on in those schools that were not reflected in the media coverage.”

But the New York Times conjured a Dickensian vision, charging that, among other things, corporal punishment is common at boys’ yeshivas. They reported the New York Police Department “investigated more than a dozen claims of child abuse at the schools” over five years. Seemingly, no criminal charges were filed.

Krakowski commented, “Almost all [yeshivas] have eliminated corporal punishment. … Twenty years ago, that was the default punishment, you’d get a slap on the hand. But if that’s the culture, you make it very easy for somebody to abuse that. … I’m glad they’ve stopped.”

No school should use corporal punishment. For the sake of student safety, though, it’s imperative to ask if this signifies a larger problem.

The New York Times tried to downplay the use of corporal punishment in public schools, rounding down the number of incidents, but a Times Union investigation found: “In recent years, the state Education Department has documented nearly 18,000 complaints of corporal punishment in public and charter schools across New York, although corporal punishment is generally banned. Investigators and school officials substantiated more than 1,600 of those complaints from 2016 through 2021, according to a Times Union review of state Education Department records. … The vast majority of the substantiated complaints were in New York City public schools.”

The New York Times further painted the Hasidic community as what used to be derisively called “the undeserving poor.” After graduation, the paper claimed yeshiva students were shunted off into “a cycle of joblessness and dependency.” The New York Times shames no other demographic group for using public assistance, but there’s also abundant evidence that this is not true.

As Orthodox Jewish advocacy group Agudath Israel of America noted, a 2021 Nishma Research study found the median Hasidic household income was $102,000. A study that Krakowski is “working on, that is still in progress, shows a median income of $115,000” among 30-, 35-, and 40-year-old graduates from a “weak” yeshiva. Meanwhile, the U.S. Census Bureau reported the “real median household income [for all Americans] was $70,784 in 2021.”

Orthodox Jewish Public Affairs Council data compared employment among men ages 20-64 in New York City, in the Hasidic enclave Kiryas Joel, and statewide. At 75%, Kiryas Joel outperformed the Bronx’s 68.7% but was slightly below the statewide 76.8% and Queens’s 79.7%. OJPAC rightly emphasized that Hasidic families skew younger and larger than average, which distorts comparisons.

It’s “a very big [media-driven] misconception” that Hasidic men “study Torah all day,” said Frieda Vizel, who grew up as part of the Satmar Hasidic community and now leads walking tours of Hasidic Brooklyn. “Especially in Williamsburg, the men are usually very active in the workforce,” Satmar men especially. “The men are the breadwinners. The Satmar Rebbe thought men shouldn’t sit in Kollel [yeshiva for married men] unless they’re really qualified for it. They’re fairly impatient with men not going out and earning a living.”

And members of the community aim to improve that further with innovative programs that meet the needs of Hasidic would-be professionals. Raizel Reit founded Testing and Training International, which the New York Times mischaracterized as “an online firm.” (Pre-pandemic, classes met at a Brooklyn public school, but the pandemic pushed classes online.) Brooklyn-based TTI matches students, many of them Orthodox Jews, with culturally sensitive bachelor’s and master’s level programs in their preferred fields.

The New York Times raised suspicions about TTI’s special education training program because “Students take weekly online classes and can obtain a provisional license in a few months, records show.” Reit responded, “The Times writes as if we’re doing something bizarre. This is a New York initiative [to accelerate teachers’ entry into classrooms]. Our partner, Daemen University, is one of the very many colleges offering” a state certification known as the Transitional B program. “Students are closely monitored, and [this program] has excellent results. So why should it be criticized? Because the students are Orthodox Jews?”

Reflecting on the hostile line of questioning from the New York Times, Reit commented that she’s doing what critics like the New York Times claim to want: “I’m taking yeshiva graduates and professionalizing them. They’re working hard and are excellent teachers.”

Those teachers are preparing to help and support the special needs children of New York. And while the way a community, or state, treats its children speaks volumes, the treatment of its special needs children may be even more revealing.

Sheva Tauby, a business owner and mother of eight, has a special needs son, and she gushed, “The respect and seriousness, the attentiveness at the school my son goes to, is unparalleled. ... We believe he was created for a purpose, so there’s no reason he should get less services than other kids. Anyone with special needs kids in the religious community, we have tons of community programs. ... What they do is unbelievable.”

Esther Horowitz, a mother of 11 and grandmother who does special education tutoring and evaluations for children of all backgrounds across New York City, said yeshiva “teachers are on top of things. Every child gets tested as soon as there’s a problem so there’s no problem later on in life.”

By contrast, the New York Times saw a community greedily gorging on special education funding: “In Orthodox Jewish religious schools, particularly in parts of the Hasidic community,” a policy enacted by then-Mayor Bill de Blasio in 2014 “has also led to a windfall of government money for services that are sometimes not needed, or even provided.”

The New York Times reported that an unspecified number of unnamed firms “now bill more than $200 an hour per student.” They allowed that company representatives “said that it was common practice across the industry not to pay employees the full amount billed per hour,” but only after claiming that “[non-school-affiliated] officers say the companies that provide services in yeshivas stand out for the rates they charge and the amount of money they receive.” The article also scrutinized a maximalist pool of schools: “More than $350 million a year now goes to private companies that provide services in Hasidic and Orthodox schools” [italics added for emphasis].

Horowitz responded, “I have never seen anyone I know” get more than $200. “People are earning $70-$85 an hour through an agency. If agencies are desperate, they might offer more. If you go directly to the Board of Education, you can get $150 an hour [in Manhattan], which is more than the agency pays.”

Chany Halpern, mother of eight, grandmother of many, and daughter of Holocaust survivors, has three daughters who have worked with special needs children. One daughter has advised schools and pediatricians about recognizing occupational therapy candidates earlier, thereby minimizing the amount of therapy needed. What the New York Times paints as greed is actually early intervention, intended to save everybody time and money over the long haul.

Unfortunately, it is the special needs children who will suffer for the New York Times’s errors. According to Horowitz, “The Board of Education is already more skeptical of [Hasidic] children who need help because of the Times’s stories.”

What do elected officials think about the New York Times and its allegations? New York state Sen. Simcha Felder sees a “shameless mission to trample, besmirch, and decimate religious and traditional values at every opportunity.”

New York City Councilman Kalman Yeger called the series “part and parcel of a deliberate effort over the last several years to ‘otherize’ Orthodox Jews, to say we’re not part of society.” As for yeshivas, “some are great, some can do a bit better, some may need a little help. But that’s not the gist of the Times's story. Fact is, the vast majority of yeshivas are superb in their approach and their outcomes, and sadly, the same cannot be said for the vast majority of public schools.”

For many Hasidim, the campaign against yeshivas recalls “the first decade of Soviet rule,” explained Dovid Margolin, senior editor at Chabad.org. “There was a section of the Communist Party called the Yevsektsiya, the Jewish section. They, themselves Jews, sometimes even from Hasidic families who left the community, were far more zealous with the Jews than any other anti-religious organizations in the Soviet Union, and they were successful. They closed yeshivas and took away synagogues. It was a full-time job for a decade.”

Margolin continued, “There's a deep, historic trauma of people going to the government and trying to shut yeshivas down. There are people in the community whose parents, students in these yeshivas whose grandparents survived the Gulags or were even executed as a part of this campaign. These stories are so deeply ingrained in the Hasidic community.”

Acknowledging “there are gaps [in the yeshiva system because] there are in every educational system,” Rabbi Aaron Kotler, president emeritus of the Haredi (though not Hasidic) Beth Medrash Govoha in Lakewood, New Jersey, opined, “The best arbiters of any educational system are typically the people internally in the system who want the best results for their families.” But in this case, “the Times is calling for enforced social change, and you do that at peril with any community.”

Melissa Langsam Braunstein (@slowhoneybee) is an independent writer in metropolitan Washington.
אייוועלט קרעדיט סקור
viewtopic.php?p=4788262#p4788262
שמחהלע
שר האלף
תגובות: 1526
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: מיטוואך יאנואר 10, 2018 12:50 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך שמחהלע »

BOMBSHELL: Email Obtained From State Shows That NY
:Times Knew Claims About Yeshivas Were FALSE
https://www.theyeshivaworld.com/?p=2203925
אוועטאר
יעקב לעהמאן
שר האלף
תגובות: 1287
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: דינסטאג אקטאבער 25, 2022 5:56 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך יעקב לעהמאן »

שמחהלע האט געשריבן: דאנערשטאג יוני 29, 2023 9:09 am
BOMBSHELL: Email Obtained From State Shows That NY
:Times Knew Claims About Yeshivas Were FALSE
https://www.theyeshivaworld.com/?p=2203925
WOW!!!
can they be sued or something?
אני מאמין באמונה שלימה שהוא לבדו עשה ועושה ויעשה לכל המעשים
כי לא יטוש השם את עמו ונחלתו לא יעזוב
ידיד כל חי
שר שלשת אלפים
תגובות: 3285
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: מיטוואך דעצעמבער 07, 2011 10:01 am

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך ידיד כל חי »

שמחהלע האט געשריבן: דאנערשטאג יוני 29, 2023 9:09 am
BOMBSHELL: Email Obtained From State Shows That NY
:Times Knew Claims About Yeshivas Were FALSE
https://www.theyeshivaworld.com/?p=2203925
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1HPBdV4 ... sp=sharing
אוועטאר
ארחיקה נדד
שר חמשת אלפים
תגובות: 5907
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: זונטאג נאוועמבער 24, 2019 9:11 pm
לאקאציע: מ'וואנדערט

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך ארחיקה נדד »

איך פארשטיי נישט די באמשעל. סך הכל בעהט ראזענטאהל די סטעיט אויסצוקלארן די נאמבערס, היות ביי געוויסע מוסדות זעהט ער אז די ספעשל עד ענראולמענט (גענומען פון די סטעיט דאטא) איז מער ווי די גאנצע מוסד בכלל.

נא? ווער זאגט אז דאס האט ער פאבליצירט? זיין אימעיל דאטום איז נאוועמבער 4, די שונד ארטיקל איז ערשינען באלד צוויי חדשים שפעטער.
כבוד המנהל, ווען קומט א המשך?
אוועטאר
דרייטצעך
שר ששת אלפים
תגובות: 6156
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: מיטוואך דעצעמבער 29, 2021 5:13 pm
לאקאציע: וואו דרייטצעך א איד?

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך דרייטצעך »

כ'מיין אז די סיבה איז ווייל אין זיין אימעיל צו קראסנא מוסד באציט ער זיך אז די סיבה פארוואס ער נעמט נישט אן די מוסדות נומבערס ווייל ער האט נישט קיין סיבה צו טראכטן אז די גאווערמענטס נומבערס זענען פאלש, אבער פון דעם אימעיל זעט מען קלאר אז ער האט יא געוואסט אז די גאווערמענט נומבערס קענען נישט זיין אמת, אויב אזוי פארוואס גלייבט ער נישט די מוסדות נומערן?
= שומר ישראל שמור שארית ישראל =
איך בין נישט קיין דעמאקראט, נישט קיין ריפובליקען און ניטאמאל קיין אינדיפעדענט, איך באנוץ זיך מיט מיין אייגענעם שכל...
אבער אנטקעגן דעת תורה פון מיינע רבי'ס בטלה דעתי!
אוועטאר
פאליטישע עקספערט
שר עשרת אלפים
תגובות: 17780
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: זונטאג אוגוסט 15, 2021 8:23 pm
פארבינד זיך:

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך פאליטישע עקספערט »

בקיצור, אז ס'זאל אפילו מאכן א קריץ אינעם ניו יארק טיימס זאל ער עס לופטערן אין די געהעריגע מידיא, נישט אינעם יון שונד בלעטל אנע מינדערסטע זשורנאליסטישע סטאנדארטן אזש די בילדער אויפן זייטל הייסן 'וואטסאפפ-אימעדש-וכו',
אמרתי בחפזי
אנשי שלומינו
תגובות: 8
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: דאנערשטאג מאי 14, 2020 6:06 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך אמרתי בחפזי »

ניו יארק דעפארטמענט אוו עדיוקעישאן האט היינט געשיקט די רעזולטאטן פון די לאנגיעריגע אויספארשונג אויף די מאסטער מסירה.

זיי האבן געטראפן אז רוב ישיבות זענען נישט גוט, ה"י, און האבן עס געשיקט צו די סטעיט פאר ווייטערדיגע שריט.
אוועטאר
כ'קעניש דיסיידן
שר האלף
תגובות: 1130
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: זונטאג פעברואר 19, 2023 3:41 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך כ'קעניש דיסיידן »

ברייטבארט איז ארויסגעקומען מיט אן ארטיקל אז די סטעיט האט מיטגעארבעט מיט די ניו יארק טיימס אויף די ארטיקלען.

The New York Times collaborated with the New York State government to produce its now-infamous series of stories targeting Orthodox Jewish schools, according to over 800 pages of emails obtained by Breitbart News.
My comments are for illustration purposes only, they do not reflect the opinions of the author
נעגא נעגא נעגא-טיוויטי איז א נגע נגע נגע צרעת
אוועטאר
Yes 1
שר חמישים
תגובות: 78
זיך איינגעשריבן אום: מיטוואך מארטש 13, 2019 12:35 pm

Re: נ.י. טיימס פובליצירט העסליכע ארטיקל קעגן חסידים און ישיבות

  • ציטיר
  • צו לייגן א דאנק דארפט איר זיין אריינגעלאגט

תגובה דורך Yes 1 »

כ'קעניש דיסיידן האט געשריבן: דינסטאג אוגוסט 08, 2023 3:03 pm
ברייטבארט איז ארויסגעקומען מיט אן ארטיקל אז די סטעיט האט מיטגעארבעט מיט די ניו יארק טיימס אויף די ארטיקלען.

The New York Times collaborated with the New York State government to produce its now-infamous series of stories targeting Orthodox Jewish schools, according to over 800 pages of emails obtained by Breitbart News.

פאליטישע קאך לעפל - יצחק קלאר
ד' ראה פ״ג
https://www.yiddish24.com/news/61/89106
שרייב תגובה

צוריק צו “אקטועלע נייעס”